Yes, Your Nonprofit Is in Maine, but What Else Should Donors Know?

It’s year-end appeal season, and nonprofits across Maine are working on letters, emails, and social posts asking people to give. Somewhere in many of those messages will be a reminder that the organization serves Maine people. That’s a reasonable thing to include. But how much are we counting on that connection to accomplish?

Our November Mindsets of Maine focus report looks at charitable giving and whether it matters that a nonprofit is based in Maine. Sixty-two percent said it matters at least somewhat. Given what we’ve learned about Mainers’ preferences for local businesses and organizations, that’s hardly surprising.

We also asked people who have donated to a nonprofit what usually persuades them to support a particular organization. The most common reason, selected by 66%, was that the organization addresses a need they consider important. Next came a need that affects someone close to them (45%), followed by a need that requires immediate help (39%). The organization’s connection to Maine ranked fourth, with just under a third choosing it as a reason to give.

These results came from different questions, so I wouldn’t use them to declare that being local gets an organization considered while something else closes the gift. What they do suggest, however, is that a Maine connection deserves some space in your appeal. People also need to understand the problem, why it matters, and what their donation can actually help accomplish.

I’m especially interested in the 45% who say they’re persuaded to give when a need affects someone close to them. When you work with these issues every day, it’s easy to forget that other people may not understand who needs help or why. “Food insecurity” might be familiar language to us, but a donor may connect more readily with the retired couple down the road whose grocery budget keeps shrinking as their other bills go up. That kind of detail helps people recognize the need in their own communities and understand why someone they know might need your help.

As someone who serves on a nonprofit board, I’d want us to read our appeal with that in mind. Have we explained the need in a way people can recognize? Have we shown what their support makes possible? Or have we assumed that readers already understand those things because they know our organization?

There’s more to explore in the full report, including differences among our three Maine mindsets in both their giving habits and what motivates them to donate. We’ll share those findings, along with our perspective on what they mean for Maine nonprofits and the businesses that support them, next week.

For now, if you’re reviewing a year-end appeal, take another look at what you’ve asked “local” to explain. Serving Maine people matters to many prospective donors. If you give them a clear picture of how you help those people; you’ll give that Maine connection even more substance.